How Leaders Become Strategists
Want to cut through the fluff and build a strategy that actually works? Join Dr. Richard Rumelt, UCLA Anderson Emeritus Professor and author of The Crux, as he reveals how top leaders and companies diagnose critical problems—and take action to overcome them. **Key points from the video:** * **Strategy involves diagnosing challenges and building coherent solutions**. * **A good strategy is a coherent mix of policy and action designed to surmount a high-stakes challenge**. * **The Crux is the most difficult part of a challenge**, and the Crux principle involves focusing on the most important challenge where you can handle the Crux. * **Setting financial performance goals is not strategy**; it is ambition. * **A strategic thinking mindset involves diagnosis** to figure out what's going on, why things are difficult, and what difficulties can be overcome. * **Innovation is part of strategy**, but not the whole thing. Successful innovation leads to advantage and profits. * **Management by objectives and strategy are not comparable concepts**. Strategy involves managing by action, not by objectives. * **Vision, mission, and value statements may keep people employed, but they are not essential for strategy**. A motto can express exuberance without limiting actions. * **A strategy should have its own budget** separate from the regular operating budget. * **It's important to look at challenges within your industry** and address value denials, which are things that should be for sale but aren't. Dr. Rumelt also shares examples of good and bad strategies from companies like Dean Foods, Royal field, Nokia, Marvel, and SpaceX. He also touches upon his experiences with Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld and the Foundry process he uses to help companies develop challenge-based strategies. Dr. Richard Rumelt's presentation, "How Leaders Become Strategists Conference Day 1," focuses on his concept of a challenge-based strategy and the Crux—the most difficult part of a challenge that must be overcome to achieve success. Below is a YouTube timeline of the key topics and case studies discussed in the video: Introduction and Strategy Critique [01:07] Introduction of Dr. Richard Rumelt: The host introduces Dr. Rumelt, author of The Crux, and outlines his focus on strategy as diagnosing challenges and building coherent solutions. [03:24] Presentation Begins & The Crux: Dr. Rumelt discusses The Crux as his attempt to answer how one actually creates a good strategy. [04:53] 👎 Case Study: Dean Foods (Bad Strategy): An example of "bad strategy" where the company's plan was a "wish list" of ambitions (e.g., lowest costs) that failed to address the true challenge of a dysfunctional, subsidized milk market, ultimately leading to bankruptcy. [07:15] 👎 Case Study: Royal Field (Ambitions, not Strategy): An example of a company confusing financial goals (e.g., 15% profit growth) with strategy, which Dr. Rumelt stresses are merely ambitions. [10:16] Defining Strategy: Strategy is defined as a "coherent mix of policy and action designed to surmount a high-stakes challenge" (referencing the Greek strategia). The Crux Principle and Case Studies [12:17] Introducing The Crux Principle: The term Crux is introduced using the analogy of bouldering (the hardest part of the climb). The Crux Principle is: "Don't accept a challenge unless you can handle the Crux." [16:30] 👍 Case Study: SpaceX and Elon Musk: Musk's strategy is highlighted as focusing on the Crux problem of high cost due to non-reusable rockets. His solution—designing the rocket to land on its tail—reduced costs by a factor of 28 compared to the Space Shuttle. [21:16] 👎 Case Study: Nokia (Ignoring the Crux): Nokia's collapse is shown as an example of a company with a high-minded mission that failed to address the core challenge, or Crux: the industry's shift from hardware to software dominance. [25:17] 👍 Case Study: Marvel (The Marvel Universe): Kevin Feige's successful strategy involved solving the Crux: how to monetize 4,700 comic book characters when Hollywood only wanted to license one at a time. The solution was the Marvel Universe, packaging many characters together in films. Strategy Implementation and Q&A [27:50] The Strategy "Foundry" Process: Dr. Rumelt describes his strategic process, called a Foundry, which is an intensive, challenge-based approach focused on diagnosing the most critical challenge and designing coherent actions. [32:26] Q&A: The Strategy Foundry Process and Ego: Discussion on using confidential interviews and direct feedback to overcome "ego tripping" and bureaucratic resistance when the strategy challenges existing power structures. [43:13] Q&A: Innovation in Strategy: Dr. Rumelt confirms that innovation should be part of a good strategy, especially when a business approaches maturity, necessitating a shift to a "faster horse." [53:17] Q&A: MBO and Strategy Budget: He clarifies that strategy is managed by action, not by objectives, and stresses the need for a separate "strategy budget" for new, extra-ordinary actions outside of normal operating funds. [55:53] Q&A: Use of Mission/Vision/Values: Dr. Rumelt argues that Mission, Vision, and Value statements are generally unhelpful, suggesting that a simple motto is better, and that a leader's values are expressed by their actions, not statements. [57:52] Q&A: Looking at Industry Challenges: He advises looking at challenges faced by customers, competitors, and the industry, and introduces the concept of "value denials" (something that should be for sale but isn't) to find opportunities. [01:01:31] Closing Remarks: The hosts thank Dr. Rumelt and summarize the presentation's key takeaways.
Not Rated Yet