• Big Mistakes

When You Refuse a Bailout Out of Pride: Nissan's Likely Bankruptcy

Why Automotive Turnaround Strategists Rewatch This 17-Minute Nissan Pride-Driven Collapse Carlos Ghosn rescued Nissan from $32B debt in late 1990s, turning $6.46B loss into $2.7B profit first year through "21,000 workers laid off, five Japanese plants closed." Created Renault-Nissan-Mitsubishi Alliance becoming "global juggernaut." Then 2018 scandal removed him, leaving leadership vacuum. CEO Uchida's "Nissan NEXT" achieved 5% operating margin target by 2023—but "unfortunately wouldn't last." The hybrid strategic blindness at 11:08 exposes catastrophic bet: "Nissan had no hybrids, did make Rogue Hybrid but discontinued it in 2020—thought with EVs on rise hybrids were on way out." Reality: "hybrid sales in 2023 leapt to almost 1.2 million US sales up 53% from 2022, globally over 4 million, growing more than EVs—plug-in hybrids showed 65% year-over-year increase 2024 versus battery EVs 23%." Nissan "had absolutely no hybrids to offer, bet on wrong horse." The inventory death spiral at 09:50 quantifies operational failure: "Early 2024 inventory over 640,000, half just sitting in dealerships—back in 2021 inventory just 250,000." Model year transition "between 2023 and 2024 Rogue models did not go smoothly led to increase in inventory"—ran "massive discounts, prices slashed, gave dealers cash incentives" but profits "fell 99% all way to 995 million yen or $6.5 million, over 9,000 jobs cut worldwide." The Honda merger pride rejection at 15:25 reveals ego over survival: Honda proposed Nissan become subsidiary "as opposed to more equal merger—costs bloated, cars weren't selling, management slow, felt Nissan could never recover on own." Despite Honda being "5 times Nissan's size, they weren't equal" but "Nissan had deep sense of pride, found this outlandish." February 6 2025 Uchida "informed Mibe face-to-face deal is off—Nissan's share price fell below $3, down 80%." The 100% bankruptcy probability at 16:39 quantifies terminal state: "Reported first operating loss in over 4 years: -79.1 billion yen or $-534 million, factories on brink of closure." Current situation: "$50 billion in debt yet no profits—Macroaxis currently gives them 100% probability of going bankrupt, that help from Honda would have been very helpful but that's gone now, pride comes before fall." Strategic lesson: discontinuing bridge products (hybrids) while betting entirely on nascent technology (EVs) creates product portfolio gap during transition—when combined with pride preventing rescue merger, operational failures become existential. 5 Key Timestamps: [01:22] The Carlos Ghosn $9.16B Turnaround – Late 1990s Nissan "drowning in $32 billion debt" during 1997 Asian Financial Crisis, "Renault bought controlling stake 36.8%, came Carlos Ghosn as new CEO, pledged to get Nissan back into green within year." Massive cost cutting: "five Japanese plants closed, 21,000 workers laid off, consultants cut, debt slashed"—first year "Nissan's net profits climbed to $2.7 billion from loss of $6.46 billion, reported best financial results in history, escaped bankruptcy, Ghosn had done impossible" [04:04] The Leadership Scandal Vacuum – November 2018 "Ghosn removed as chairman for under-reporting income and using company assets for personal reasons, fled to Lebanon where authorities couldn't catch him"—scandal created "PR nightmare, shares fell, Ghosn had led alliance over decade and with him gone so was stability." CEO Saikawa "also involved in pay scandal and resigned"—new CEO Makoto Uchida appointed October 2019, "share price halved between 2018 and 2019, then came COVID-19, first quarter 2020 reported 50.5% drop in revenue, operating loss $1.44 billion, net loss $2.67 billion, back in red" [11:08] The Hybrid Strategic Bet Catastrophe – "Nissan had no hybrids, did make Rogue Hybrid but discontinued it in 2020—thought with EVs on rise hybrids were on way out." Reality: "hybrid sales in 2023 leapt to almost 1.2 million US sales up 53% from 2022, globally over 4 million, hybrids even growing more than EVs—plug-in hybrids showing 65% year-over-year increase 2024, for comparison battery EVs grew by 23%." Electric battery market growing "massively, people often attribute that to EVs but in reality it's hybrids doing heavy lifting—Nissan had absolutely no hybrids to offer, bet on wrong horse" [09:50] The 640K Unit Inventory Death Spiral – "Early 2024 inventory over 640,000, half just sitting in dealerships—back in 2021 inventory just 250,000." Problem: "transition between model year 2023 and 2024 Rogue models did not go smoothly led to increase in inventory, Sentra having similar issues some caused by Rogue bottleneck." Response: "ran massive discounts, prices slashed, gave dealers cash incentives if they could sell off inventory but doesn't address root problem why cars weren't selling in first place"—profits "fell 99% all way to 995 million yen or $6.5 million, over 9,000 jobs cut worldwide, factories scaled back, dividends suspended" [14:48] The Pride-Driven Honda Merger Rejection – Honda proposed "cost cutting, certain plants had to be shut down but Nissan wouldn't budge, politically sensitive according to insiders"—Honda management "began to see Nissan's management as slow." Critical revision: "Nissan would become subsidiary of Honda as opposed to more equal merger—costs bloated, cars weren't selling, management slow, felt Nissan could never recover on own." Despite "Honda being 5 times Nissan's size they weren't equal" but "Nissan had deep sense of pride, found this outlandish"—February 6 2025 "Uchida informed Mibe face-to-face deal is off, Nissan's share price fell below $3 down 80%, Uchida resigned month later." Current state: "$50 billion debt yet no profits, Macroaxis gives them 100% probability going bankrupt" Read More

• 18 min
• 80 views